News Made Clear · Loading…
News Made Clear · Loading…

BBC interviews and a Russian activist’s six-year sentence highlight risks for some people returned after failed asylum claims. Official removal figures cannot show how many dissidents are among them.
Russians refused asylum in the United States have described being questioned by security officers after returning to Moscow in new BBC interviews. In a separate case, activist Leonid Melekhin has received a six-year sentence in Russia following his return after a failed US asylum claim. The accounts show what can be at stake for individuals, but deportation totals do not reveal how many anti-war activists or deserters are being sent back.
A woman identified by the BBC as Katya said officers from Russia’s FSB questioned her for hours when a deportation flight arrived in December 2025. She said male passengers were given papers requiring them to register with a military enlistment office. Another passenger and an activist backed her account, according to the BBC, which says it also saw supporting documents and photographs. Katya said she was released but that police still call and visit her. Registration papers do not establish that anyone on the flight was sent to fight in Ukraine. [1]
Melekhin’s asylum claim was rejected while he was in US immigration detention, and he was arrested after returning to Russia in July 2025, according to Mediazona. On 5 October 2026, a military court in Yekaterinburg sentenced him to six years in a penal colony on two counts of ‘justifying terrorism’. Mediazona reported that the case involved a post showing an image of a protest featuring Vladimir Putin’s likeness and a separate internet comment whose contents are unknown. The proceedings were closed; local outlet Vechernie Vedomosti said the court’s press office confirmed the sentence. [5] [6] [10]
The BBC describes Melekhin as deported. His state-appointed lawyer told Mediazona that Melekhin had asked to be sent back after his asylum claim failed, while an acquaintance doubted he would have returned voluntarily. Those accounts leave the precise terms of his departure from the US unclear; they do not alter the fact of his subsequent arrest and sentence in Russia. [1] [6]
Another BBC interviewee, a former Russian soldier identified as Artyom, said he was returned through Egypt after the US refused him asylum. He said he was held in a Russian military detention facility, escaped and is now outside Russia again. The Guardian and the Russian outlet Vyorstka separately reported flights through Egypt in 2025 and interviewed other returnees who described questioning in Moscow. Those reports do not establish what happened to every passenger.
11 listed sources · explore evidence, limitations and provenance.
Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.
Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.
Ask your question with @newsmadeclear or @nmc. You may receive 5 starter credits once after checks on your confirmed email and browser. The offer is once per person; extra accounts do not entitle you to another bonus. There is no monthly refill. Previous balances remain. A question costs 1 credit, including additional research you permit. A source you provide that demonstrably improves the article earns 5 credits. If your question helps Astra find the missing source and improve the article, you receive 1 credit back.
Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.
Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.
Loading comments…
Interested in advertising with News Made Clear? Explore our pilot.
A US immigration officer stated in a federal court case that 1,273 Russian citizens had been removed to Russia in the 2025 financial year up to 13 September. That figure counts nationality and destination, not political views or treatment on arrival. German government figures record seven removals to Russia in 2023, 66 in 2024 and 111 from January to October 2025. The German total was 283 in 2021, so the rise from the 2023 low is not evidence of an uninterrupted long-term increase. Nor do the totals identify dissidents among those removed. [4] [2]
Germany’s protection rate for Russian citizens fell from 29% in 2023 to 6.9% in 2025 when procedural decisions are excluded. Those rates cover decisions on applicants from Russia generally, not specifically on anti-war activists. The German government has itself described a dramatic deterioration in human rights in Russia, including growing repression of critics of the war. Its asylum agency told the BBC that protection depends on a well-founded fear of persecution in the individual case. [2] [3] [1]
That individual assessment is also disputed in Finland. A couple identified by the BBC as Mikhail and Dasha fear removal after repeated asylum refusals. The Finnish Immigration Service concluded, according to the BBC’s account of its decision, that there was no reasonable basis to believe they would face serious rights violations if returned; Amnesty International, which supports them, says they face a real risk of detention, prosecution, imprisonment and torture. The couple had not been returned when the BBC reported their case. [1]