BBC test finds errors in AI Black Friday TV recommendations
A BBC test of ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Alexa found incorrect prices, dead links and limited retailer coverage in AI-generated Black Friday TV recommendations.

A BBC test of four AI assistants found that their Black Friday TV recommendations were often difficult to rely on: some prices were wrong, several links led to unavailable products, and Amazon’s Alexa searched only its own store.
The reporters asked ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Alexa to find a UK 55-inch television costing £500 to £700, prioritising picture quality and gaming. The BBC said the exercise was not a rigorous scientific test, but found mixed results across the free versions of the tools.
ChatGPT suggested four TVs, but links for two led to products no longer listed by the retailers. Another option exceeded the budget and was unavailable online. Claude’s links included dead pages and round-ups of 2025 deals. Gemini gave a correct price for one TCL model, but it was sold out at a named retailer; another model was £60 more expensive at Currys than the chatbot had said.
Alexa’s listed prices were correct, according to the BBC, but its recommendations came from Amazon alone. It included a 50-inch Sony despite the request for a 55-inch TV, and advised users to check other retailers because prices and guarantees can vary.
The findings come as retailers and technology companies introduce AI shopping features. A YouGov survey covering 19 countries found that the UK ranked second-last for the proportion of people who said they had used AI to help them shop. Of those who expected to shop around Black Friday, 36% said they did not plan to use an AI tool.
Naureen Mohammed, who advises businesses on appearing in AI results, told the BBC that out-of-date retailer prices could lead chatbots to present last year’s prices as current deals. She said Amazon appeared in half of the responses in her own analysis of UK Black Friday technology recommendations, with Currys close behind.
Consumer group Which? has also warned that inaccurate AI prices can add work for shoppers. Its senior researcher Hannah Walsh said incorrect prices could waste time or cause people to miss products that are actually within budget.
Alex Hughes, a technology journalist who used ChatGPT’s agent mode to search for a television during last year’s sales, told the BBC he probably would not use AI for Black Friday deals again. Although he said the tool saved him time, he found the live price information inconsistent and often incorrect. When he later bought one of the models it had suggested, he found it cheaper in a physical shop.
Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.
From the discussion
Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.
Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.
Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.
Loading comments…