All news articles
CategoryGeneral
RegionsUSA
ContinentsNorth America

Judge denies Lindsay Clancy’s bid to dismiss murder case

AI-generated section illustration
Loading statistics…

A judge has denied Lindsay Clancy’s motion to dismiss the murder case over the deaths of her three children, finding that a retrial after the first jury deadlocked would not violate her double-jeopardy rights.

What has changed? · 09/11/2026, 21:51 UTC

Review information is loading.

A Massachusetts prosecutor has told a judge that Lindsay Clancy could face a new trial over the deaths of her three children, but the district attorney says he has not yet made a final decision.

Asked at a hearing on 2 November how the state would proceed, assistant district attorney Jennifer Sprague said: “This would be a retrial.” She added that its form would depend on the judge’s rulings. Prosecutors have not said whether they would pursue the same charges.

District Attorney Timothy Cruz told local television station WHDH that he was waiting for more information, including judicial decisions, before deciding what to do.

Clancy was tried on three counts of first-degree murder over the deaths of Cora, five, Dawson, three, and eight-month-old Callan at their home in Duxbury in 2023. She pleaded not guilty. At trial, her lawyers did not dispute that she killed the children, but argued that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and was not criminally responsible. Prosecutors argued that she acted deliberately and understood her actions were wrong.

Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial on 4 September after the jury could not reach a unanimous verdict. Jurors reported an 11-to-one split in favour of finding Clancy not guilty by reason of insanity.

Her lawyers now argue that the mistrial was unnecessary and that a second trial would violate her protection against being tried twice for the same offence, known as double jeopardy. They say the judge should have questioned the lone dissenting juror more closely after the jury foreperson raised concerns that the juror was not following instructions on reasonable doubt.

Sprague argued that Sullivan had properly handled the deadlock and that further questioning risked interfering with the jury’s deliberations. The judge also heard a defence request to preserve records and question the juror, and a prosecution request to restrict lawyers’ public comments about the case.

Sullivan scheduled another hearing for 16 November and said he would do his best to rule on the dismissal request by then. He suggested that, if a retrial goes ahead, March 2027 could be a realistic date.

Update

A Massachusetts judge has rejected Lindsay Clancy’s bid to dismiss the murder case over the deaths of her three children, ruling that a retrial would not breach her protection against double jeopardy after the first jury failed to reach a verdict.

Judge William Sullivan said the jury’s deadlock made a mistrial necessary. The ruling allows prosecutors to pursue another trial, but they have not yet said whether they will seek the same charges or reduce them.

Clancy’s first trial ended in a mistrial in September, when jurors could not agree. Her lawyers argued Sullivan should have removed the juror who favoured conviction and allowed deliberations to continue, rather than ending the trial.

Sullivan also rejected a defence request to investigate the holdout juror and denied prosecutors’ request for a gag order. He said the juror’s privacy and the confidentiality of jury deliberations weighed against further inquiry. Prosecutors could seek a gag order again if circumstances change, ABC News reported.

Clancy has not denied killing her children in 2023. Her defence says she was suffering from severe postpartum psychosis; prosecutors argue the killings were intentional.

A hearing is scheduled for 16 November to discuss the next steps. Sullivan has said he would like a retrial to begin in March 2027, but prosecutors have not announced their plans.

Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.

About this discussion and AI questions

Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.

Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.

Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.

Loading comments…