All news articles

Judge weighs Trump administration request to lift Kennedy Center closure ban

The Trump administration wants to close the main building for two years. A congresswoman challenging the plan says trustees were not given crucial information about alternatives.

The Kennedy Center seen from the Potomac River
The Kennedy Center seen from the Potomac River · · Tom · CC BY 3.0 · Archive photograph, for illustration
Loading statistics…

US District Judge Christopher Cooper heard arguments in Washington on 19 November on the Trump administration’s request to lift the injunction blocking its planned two-year closure of the Kennedy Center’s main building. He did not rule at the hearing and said he would try to decide as soon as he could, MS NOW reported.

Congresswoman Joyce Beatty, a trustee of the performing arts centre, brought the challenge. In May, Cooper found that the board had likely breached its duties by voting to close without sufficient information or a meaningful opportunity for trustees to weigh the decision. The order blocked implementation of the March decision to wind down programming and close for renovations; it did not ban repairs or limited closures around remedial work.

The government argues that circumstances have changed because trustees received more information and voted again for a two-year closure on 13 August and 15 September. Its lawyers say a phased renovation while the building remains partly open would take about four years and bring additional costs and safety risks.

At the hearing, Cooper asked why the two-year option had not been presented when Congress was asked to fund the work. He also questioned how keeping the centre open without performances would help its finances. Beatty’s lawyer, Nathaniel Zelinsky, acknowledged that the four-year approach would cost more and raised concerns about the lack of performances.

Beatty’s lawyers argue that the later process was designed to justify a closure Trump had already chosen. They point to the short time Delta had to make its initial recommendation and to management’s input into its presentation. The government says Delta conducted an independent assessment and trustees considered the alternatives. The full Delta report was circulated after the August vote, before the board met again in September.

The lawyers also dispute the information trustees received about costs. They say Delta estimated the extra construction cost of a phased approach at $303 million, while a later JLL plan put it at $41 million. The lawyers allege that the later JLL plan was not given to the full board. They acknowledge that JLL’s plan used an adjusted scope that may overlap with projects excluded from Delta’s estimate. The government also cited JLL’s $41 million figure and maintains that trustees had enough information to decide.

Government lawyers have pointed to safety concerns, including fallen ceiling plaster and the condition of exterior panels. Beatty’s lawyers say the building remained open for almost two weeks after the plaster fell, and that a previous exterior-panel problem was addressed by restricting access to the affected area.

Cooper separately blocked the addition of Trump’s name to the centre in May. The government did not ask him to lift that ruling at this hearing, MS NOW reported.

Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.

From the discussion

Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.

Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.

Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.

Loading comments…