New York judge rejects longer ban on Trump’s taxpayer-funded ads
The New York judge found that challengers had not shown an immediate risk of harm after the midterm elections. A separate court order in Washington still restricts five of the adverts.

US District Judge Jennifer Rochon denied the request for a preliminary injunction and a stay of funding arrangements on 20 November. It was brought by Robert Hunter, a former Alabama state House candidate, the SEIU 32BJ union and its affiliated Empire PAC. Common Cause is also a plaintiff in the case but did not join the request.
Rochon said the challengers’ concerns about harm in future elections were too speculative to justify emergency relief now that the 3 November midterms had passed. But she said their claims could continue because the dispute could recur and otherwise escape review. Her decision did not settle whether the advertisements were lawful.
Rochon first blocked the use of Department of Homeland Security funds for the challenged adverts in October and suspended a $20 million funding allocation and an advertising purchase order. The original restraint was extended with the parties’ consent until 20 November. Later in October, she also ordered three additional adverts removed from official websites and their placements through authorised third parties cancelled.
When she granted the initial restraint, Rochon found the challengers were likely to succeed on claims that the spending breached federal funding rules. That was a preliminary assessment, not a final judgment.
The adverts praised President Donald Trump and criticised Democrats or democratic socialism. One featured Trump promising $5,000 to adult US citizens if Republicans won. The plaintiffs say the ads were unlawful government-funded propaganda. The White House has defended them as public service announcements.
The White House budget office increased a border agency’s allocation for commemorative events by $20 million in September. The following day, DHS placed a $20 million order with advertising agency LMD for a national media campaign. A DHS official said the order covered placement rather than production, and that about $19 million in airtime had been purchased through 11 October.
In Washington, Judge Loren AliKhan’s separate temporary order in a case brought by the Democratic National Committee runs Independently verifiedwww.democracydocket.com. Her order bars the budget office and DHS from developing or airing five specified adverts and requires them to stop distribution, including through authorised third parties.
Rochon’s ruling said no decision had been issued after a 19 November hearing on a longer injunction in the Washington case. The Democratic committee has consented to extending the temporary order beyond 25 November; the administration has not.
Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.
From the discussion
Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.
Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.
Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.
Loading comments…