Parents describe distress after childminder’s neglect plea

Parents have told the BBC of lost trust and concerns about children returning home thirsty and in dirty nappies after Amanda Mathewson pleaded guilty to neglect.
What has changed? · 07/10/2026, 17:32 UTC
Review information is loading.
Amanda Mathewson, 55, from Dunfermline, pleaded guilty at Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court to neglecting and abandoning children in her care. The court heard that she had 27 children in her home, 19 more than her registered limit of eight. [1]
Witnesses heard a child screaming at the house and found five unattended children in the garden. Inside, they found a child crying beneath the kitchen table and nine children, all under five, in an upstairs bedroom. Two of the nine were strapped into prams. The children were described as distressed but uninjured. [1]
Mathewson told police the children had been alone for at least 30 minutes, according to the court account. The court also heard that doorbell footage showed another occasion that day when children were left inside the house. The account does not establish that all 27 children were left alone together. [1]
A Care Inspectorate report published in August 2023 rated several aspects of Mathewson’s service “very good” after an inspection about a year before her arrest. The regulator called the case distressing and said it had made changes after learning from it, but did not specify them. [1]
Sheriff John MacRitchie deferred sentencing until 6 November to allow time for background reports. Mathewson remains on bail. [1]
Update
Parents of children cared for by Amanda Mathewson have described the distress and loss of trust they felt after learning about the neglect case. One parent told BBC Radio Scotland that their family had lost happy memories and had begun to look differently at eight years of family life. Another called Mathewson a “master manipulator” — the parent’s characterisation, not a court finding. [2]
The BBC reports that parents suspected their children had not eaten because their clothes remained pristine. They also described children returning home thirsty; some reported dirty nappies or dried faeces in underwear. The Courier reported that children said they had been given biscuits and sweets. The accounts raise concerns about care, but do not establish that every child went without food. [2] [3]
Parents told the BBC they had asked about signs of distress and received explanations they found plausible. According to the BBC’s account of court documents, Mathewson played loud music and kept parents from entering at drop-off to conceal how many children were in her care. [2]
Mathewson pleaded guilty to a neglect charge covering various occasions between 7 September 2023 and 26 August 2024, The Courier reported. That charged period is distinct from the eight years of family memories described by the parent. [3]
The Courier reported that Mathewson had 27 children in her care. Its account of the August 2024 discovery describes 15 children found at locations around the home while two left with her. The BBC separately says she left 27 children alone “at one stage”, without identifying that as the same episode. How many were unattended during the discovery remains unclear. [2] [3]
Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.
About this discussion and AI questions
Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.
Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.
Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.
Loading comments…