Polanski pledges no exclusion over religious ties after Greens’ Zionism vote
Polanski says he will not accept exclusion over religious or communal ties, but questions remain about how the Greens’ new Zionism policy will be applied.
What has changed? · 06/10/2026, 11:42 UTC
Review information is loading.
Green Party members voted 1,022 to 813 for the motion at their conference in Brighton. It declares Zionism a form of racism and, under party rules, becomes official policy. It will not necessarily appear in the party’s next general-election manifesto. [1]
The motion describes Zionism as support for an “ethnonationalist Jewish state” and backs a “single democratic Palestinian state in all of historic Palestine”. Party leader Zack Polanski said Zionism, as defined in the motion, was racism, but wanted the single-state reference changed. Members also rejected a change he favoured that would have specified that Jewish members should not face discipline for attending synagogues that identify as Zionist. Polanski did not vote. [1]
Deputy leader Mothin Ali backed the motion, while fellow deputy Rachel Millward called its wording “problematic”. Four of the party’s five MPs opposed it, including Carla Denyer, who warned it could alienate many Jewish people. Ali said his support did not mean he was calling all Jewish people who identify as Zionists racist. [1]
Before the vote, the Board of Deputies and Jewish Leadership Council described Zionism as an anti-racist movement and raised concerns about Jewish members and institutions in areas represented by Greens. A party spokeswoman said Jewish members would be protected, including those attending synagogues that identify as Zionist. [1]
Update
Vivien Lichtenstein, chair of Jewish Greens, said in a BBC Radio 4 Today interview reported on 5 October 2026 that it was “quite possible” she would leave the Green Party of England and Wales after its conference adopted a motion declaring Zionism a form of racism. She said she had not decided and wanted time to speak with colleagues. [2]
Lichtenstein fears the party could describe UK Jewish, Israeli-Jewish and joint Arab-Jewish organisations as Zionist and therefore racist. She said she supports some such organisations because of their work against the occupation and in support of Palestinians. She also described views within Jewish Greens as ranging from support for the motion to opposition. [4] [2]
The motion passed at the party’s Brighton conference on 4 October by 1,022 votes to 813. The Guardian described it as binding party policy, while Press Association reported that the Greens do not require all their politicians to support it. [2] [4] [3]
It defines Zionism as support for “an ethnonationalist Jewish state” and says Zionism under that definition will be treated like other forms of racism. Implementation is assigned to the party’s anti-racism policy working group as appropriate and in accordance with its ordinary practice. The motion says it targets political ideology and practice, not religious or ethnic background. Delegates rejected an amendment saying it should not be used to pressure or discipline members over affiliations with Jewish community institutions that identify as Zionist. [2] [6]
A Green Party spokesperson said motions of this kind do not materially affect governance or disciplinary procedures. The party also said Jewish members would be protected, including those attending synagogues that describe themselves as Zionist. [3] [2]
Press Association reported supporters chanting “Zionists are not welcome here” as Greens for Palestine campaigners gathered to speak to the media. Asked whether the policy meant Zionists would be kicked out, former councillor Salma Yaqoob replied “absolutely not”. [3]
The Guardian’s 5 October report quoted barrister Adam Wagner KC warning of a strong risk that the motion as passed contravened the Equality Act 2010 through discrimination and harassment of people holding Zionist beliefs and Jewish people more generally. [4]
The practical distinction is between adopting a policy and applying it. The implementation clause and rejected safeguard give a basis for Lichtenstein’s concerns, but do not themselves establish new disciplinary sanctions. The party’s assurance about procedures does not resolve Wagner’s separate concern about discrimination and harassment. [6] [3] [4]
Lichtenstein also said the motion’s proposers had not consulted Jewish Greens. Correspondence excerpts published by The Jewish Chronicle on 17 June record an invitation to comment before submission, but Jewish Greens replied that an email sent three days before the motion was posted, during a holiday period, did not amount to consultation. [2] [5]
Update
Zack Polanski, leader of the Green Party of England and Wales, says he will not accept anyone being excluded or refused engagement because of their religious or communal affiliation. His assurance follows a conference vote adopting a motion that says Zionism, as defined in the motion, should be treated like other forms of racism. [7] [11]
Delegates backed the motion at the party’s Brighton conference on 4 October by 1,022 votes to 813. [9] The Guardian describes it as binding party policy. The text defines Zionism as an ideology supporting an “ethnonationalist Jewish state” and calls for Israel to be replaced by a single democratic Palestinian state across historic Palestine, with equal rights for all. [7] [11]
Delegates also rejected an amendment that would have explicitly barred pressure or disciplinary action against members over links to Jewish institutions describing themselves as Zionist. The motion itself says it targets an ideology, not anyone’s religious or ethnic background. It assigns implementation to the anti-racism policy working group, as appropriate and under its ordinary practice. Supporters say it does not change the party’s disciplinary procedures. How it will be applied remains unresolved. [9] [11]
Labour MPs have written to the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) about the implications for Jewish members, while nine Labour MPs have referred allegations of possible antisemitic offences at the conference to Sussex Police. Police told the BBC they had received a letter and were reviewing it. The EHRC said it had not launched an investigation at that stage. Neither response is a finding on the allegations or the motion’s legality. [7]
An expulsion would not necessarily be required for a discrimination concern to arise. EHRC guidance says an indirect-discrimination challenge can concern a rule not yet applied if it would put people sharing a protected characteristic at a particular disadvantage compared with others, and would also disadvantage the individual concerned. Whether the rule is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim is also part of that test. [13]
The Guardian also reported that Sandy Ruthven, chair of Amnesty International UK’s charitable trust and a longstanding Green member, resigned over the motion and accused the party of failing to confront antisemitism. [12]
The European Green Party has separately distanced itself from the resolution, saying it conflicts with its support for a two-state solution and self-determination for Israelis and Palestinians. In its 5 October statement, it said it would immediately demand clarification from the English and Welsh party’s leadership and parliamentary group about official policy and the protection of Jewish people and party members. [8]
Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.
About this discussion and AI questions
Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.
Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.
Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.
Loading comments…