All news articles

Rogers handball penalty in Chelsea’s 4-1 defeat to Leeds reignites debate

A penalty against Morgan Rogers helped Leeds take the lead in their 4-1 win at Chelsea. BBC football correspondent Dale Johnson says the call was correct under the law, while Alan Shearer and Chelsea manager Xabi Alonso disagreed.

AI-generated editorial illustration based on the published article topic; not a documentary photograph.
Loading statistics…

A penalty that put Leeds ahead in their 4-1 win at Chelsea has renewed debate over how strictly football’s handball law should be applied, even though BBC football correspondent Dale Johnson says the decision against Morgan Rogers was correct under the rules.

Referee Michael Oliver awarded the spot-kick after Jayden Bogle’s shot struck Rogers’ raised arm. Johnson’s account says the key factor was not simply where Rogers held his arm: it was that he lifted it into the ball’s path. Had the ball hit his body with the arm in its original, lower position, there would have been no offence, he wrote.

The shot came from distance, giving Rogers more time to react. Johnson also notes that the contact was close to the boundary of the part of the arm where a handball offence can be penalised. That was the main possible reason for VAR official Michael Salisbury to ask Oliver to review the call, but VAR did not intervene.

The decision drew criticism from Match of the Day pundit Alan Shearer, who said officials were not allowed to “use common sense”. She argued that Rogers was trying to avoid being hit in the face, rather than deliberately stopping the ball. Chelsea manager Xabi Alonso also called the penalty harsh and said he would not have awarded it.

Johnson says raising an arm to protect the face can be a mitigating factor, but generally applies when a player shields their face with their hands, rather than using an arm as a barrier. He compares the call with a penalty awarded to Leeds last season after Everton defender James Tarkowski leaned into the path of a shot with his arm close to his body. Everton manager David Moyes called that decision wrong; Johnson says it was correct under the law.

The row comes amid wider frustration among some observers who want intent to count for more. Yet handball penalties remain less frequent in the Premier League than in Europe’s other leading leagues: there were 22 in 380 English top-flight matches last season, compared with 36 in Spain and 38 in Italy. There have been three in the Premier League’s first 106 matches this season, according to Johnson.

Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.

From the discussion

Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.

Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.

Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.

Loading comments…