All news articles

Senior Senate Democrat criticises Trump’s summit with Xi and Putin

Senator Jeanne Shaheen says Donald Trump was outmanoeuvred by Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin at their summit. The leaders announced plans for further talks, but few details of how they would proceed.

Temporary section image · AI illustration
Loading statistics…

What has changed? · 19/11/2026, 21:48 UTC

Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin met on 19 November at Kylin Villa in Shenzhen, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. The Associated Press reported that they spent roughly 70 minutes behind closed doors.

A declaration reported by Chinese state news agency Xinhua said the three countries would hold a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the spread of nuclear weapons. The text, reproduced by Australian broadcaster ABC, set no date for the dialogue or targets for cutting nuclear weapons. It also said the countries were committed to UN reform and planned to increase production and supply of refined oil products.

MS NOW columnist Steve Benen argued that Trump had secured “exactly zero commitments” from his counterparts. The declaration goes further than that, although a promise to talk is not a detailed nuclear arms-control agreement. AP described the agreements as modest.

Benen also quoted Richard Stengel, a former Obama administration official and MS NOW analyst, who argued that the meeting put America's principal adversaries on an equal footing with the US and restored Putin to the world order after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer called it “a historic embarrassment”, according to the column.

Stengel said no previous US president had held a trilateral meeting with Russia and China. ABC described Shenzhen as the first formal trilateral meeting of the three countries' leaders. Their predecessors have attended wider summits together: at the 2016 G20 in Hangzhou, Xi met then US president Barack Obama and Putin separately.

Trump defended engagement as the three-way meeting began. “Too often, past leaders avoided talking to nations with whom they had disagreements. And we feel the opposite,” he said, according to ABC. He later called the visit “highly consequential”.

The last nuclear arms pact between the US and Russia, New START, expired in February. China has a much smaller nuclear arsenal than either country.

Update

A senior Senate Democrat has criticised Donald Trump’s meeting with the Chinese and Russian presidents, saying it brought no benefits to Americans and weakened US security.

Senator Jeanne Shaheen, the top Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin had taken advantage of the US president at Thursday’s summit in China.

Asked by MS NOW’s Peter Alexander whether the two leaders had played Trump, Shaheen replied: “Without a doubt.” She called the meeting “a photo op that provided no deliverables, no benefits to the people of the United States” and said Trump’s approach to authoritarian leaders undermined US security.

Trump offered a different assessment, describing the visit as “highly consequential”. At the start of the meeting, he argued that dialogue with countries despite disagreements was necessary to forge peace.

After the three-way meeting in Shenzhen, the leaders issued a declaration saying their countries would hold talks on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the spread of nuclear weapons. They also said they planned to increase production and supply of refined petroleum products and committed to reforming the United Nations.

The declaration set no timetable or production target and did not mention the wars in Ukraine or Iran. The promised dialogue is not a completed nuclear agreement, though it is a commitment to further talks.

The leaders also emphasised respect for the immunity of state officials and said the International Criminal Court must not abuse its jurisdiction. The court issued an arrest warrant for Putin in 2023 over alleged war crimes involving the deportation and transfer of Ukrainian children.

Shaheen also accused Russia and China of helping Iran continue its war and attack US personnel and allies in the Middle East. The conflict began with US and Israeli strikes on Iran in February, followed by Iranian retaliation.

Reuters reported in July that US officials had acknowledged Russia provided targeting information and other support for Iranian strikes on US targets in the Gulf. A September Congressional Research Service report, citing media and think-tank accounts, also described Russian shipments of explosives, drone components and ammunition.

Separately, a US defence intelligence source told Australia’s ABC News that satellite images of US bases publicly posted by Chinese company MizarVision were helping Iranian forces identify targets. China’s foreign ministry said the imagery came from open sources and was a routine market practice.

Trump has previously said that, in his view, Russia and China were not participating in the conflict. How much the reported support has prolonged the war remains unclear.

Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.

From the discussion

Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.

Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.

Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.

Loading comments…