
‘Sister’ sketch on ‘Saturday Night Live’ spotlights women’s unpaid care burden
A fake “Saturday Night Live” advert for a sister who provides free, round-the-clock elder care has struck a nerve. Sociologist Jessica Calarco says the sketch reflects how families often rely on women to fill gaps in care.
Review information is loading.
The “Sister” sketch on “Saturday Night Live” has turned the uneven division of elder care into a family flashpoint, using a fake advert for a sister who provides round-the-clock care for free. In an opinion piece for MS NOW, sociologist Jessica Calarco argues that the joke resonates because women often end up carrying much of the work of caring for relatives.
The sketch, which aired during the 14 November episode hosted by John Mulaney, presents a man relieved that his sister can care for their father while he returns to his own life. Its punchline is the absurdity of treating a sister as a free, live-in care service. Calarco says the sketch had already drawn millions of views and social-media comments from people recognising the family dynamic.
Calarco links the joke to research showing that women in the United States spend twice as many hours on unpaid care as men. She also cites the US Department of Labor’s finding that women over 55 are the largest group providing unpaid elder care on a given day.
Her essay draws on interviews for her book, *Holding It Together: How Women Became America’s Safety Net*. One interviewee, whom she calls Virginia to protect her privacy, told Calarco that her brother said she was now the family “matriarch” after their mother was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease. Virginia, Calarco writes, was already managing much of the housework and care for her own family, despite her brother living nearby.
Calarco argues that the burden does not simply pass from men to women: it can also be shifted from women with greater resources to lower-paid and more vulnerable workers, including Black, Latina and immigrant women. She says the US system’s reliance on individual responsibility and privately purchased care leaves families struggling to meet the cost of round-the-clock support.
The essay points to publicly funded care programmes as one alternative, while noting that they have not eliminated the gender gap in unpaid care. Calarco says Dutch women spend less time on unpaid care than US women do, but Dutch men also spend less than US men. The comparison is about unpaid care, not proof that public programmes alone determine how care is divided.
Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.
About this discussion and AI questions
Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.
Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.
Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.
Loading comments…