US court suspends permit for Army’s planned Iowa explosive detonation
The Army says the degraded explosive is dangerous to move, while environmental groups fear a plume of lead dust and want alternatives examined.

A federal appeals court has temporarily suspended the permit for the US Army’s planned detonation of unstable explosive material in Iowa, leaving the operation’s future uncertain amid concerns about airborne lead.
According to a Justice Department filing, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals suspended the Environmental Protection Agency’s emergency permit on 19 November until it rules on a challenge by the Iowa Environmental Council and Sierra Club.
The permit cannot be used while the stay is in force. But the Justice Department also told the court that federal rules can allow waste treatment without an EPA permit in qualifying emergencies. Its filing did not say the Army had invoked that exception.
The Army had already postponed the operation at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown from 20 to 23 November. Federal lawyers said they intended to respond to the groups’ emergency motion by 22 November.
The Army plans to destroy 68 drums of lead azide, an explosive used in munitions. Iowa Public Radio reported that the material weighs about 9,500lb (4,300kg); that is not the amount of lead expected to enter the air.
The Army says it found the stockpile degraded and crystallised in March. Its environmental assessment says the material has become sensitive to shock and friction, making handling and transport dangerous. Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle said a forecast temperature drop could destabilise it further.
The Army considered chemical neutralisation but removed it from detailed study, saying it would require more handling of the drums and an estimated seven to 22 operating days. The environmental groups argue that the EPA did not fully consider safer alternatives before issuing the permit.
The Army expects the blast to produce a plume containing lead particles that could settle on the ground. How much lead would be released and where it would travel depend partly on the operation and the weather.
The Army, EPA and federal health department said they were preparing measures to “ensure there is no risk to the public”. The Army’s own preliminary modelling found that, without mitigation and under some weather conditions, airborne pollutants could exceed a protective-action threshold associated with temporary, reversible discomfort. The assessment expected measures such as water mist and weather restrictions to reduce emissions.
On 20 November, Illinois agencies said weather information indicated a plume could affect western and central parts of the state and requested updated modelling. Linn County emergency officials said the Army’s model used a conservative assumption that all the lead becomes airborne.
University of Iowa public health researchers told Iowa Public Radio that their concern would depend on lead concentrations in the air and on the ground; they are preparing their own monitoring. Augustana College chemistry professor Greg Domski told KWQC he was not too concerned about the fallout and thought the proposed precautions would reduce risks.
Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.
From the discussion
Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.
Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.
Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.
Loading comments…