All news articles

Was Ramaphosa’s meeting at Google scheduled in advance?

Farai Mazhindu says Google arranged a meeting for the South African president at the last minute. Hopewell Chin’ono directly disputes that account. What do the itinerary published in advance and Ramaphosa’s reception at Google show?

Editorial illustration with a silhouette for Mazhindu, a drawn portrait of Chin’ono, a calendar and the Google campus.
Loading statistics…

On 21 November, Farai Mazhindu wrote on X that Ramaphosa and his delegation had arrived at Google without a proper appointment. He said Google executive James Manyika had to arrange a photo opportunity on the spot. [1]

Original English X post alleging that Google had no real meeting and Manyika improvised one.
Farai Mazhindu on the Google meeting

Hopewell Chin’ono shared Mazhindu’s post on X that same day and responded directly. Chin’ono said the working visit to Silicon Valley had been announced before Ramaphosa’s departure and focused on AI. [2]

Original English X quote-post in which Chin’ono says the working visit was arranged and announced in advance.
Hopewell Chin’ono’s direct reply

The South African government published the itinerary on 12 November, seven days before the Google stop. It listed a visit to Google in Mountain View on 19 November and identified AI in digital trade and for small businesses as themes for that day. [4] AmCham South Africa republished the itinerary on 16 November. [5] Research Professional News also listed Google on the itinerary. [8]Checked in the originalIt listed a visit to Google in Mountain View on 19 November and identified AI in digital trade and for small businesses as themes for that day.De agenda vermeldde voor 19 november een bezoek aan Google in Mountain View en noemde AI in de digitale handel en bij kleine ondernemingen als thema’s voor die dag. Advance programme for the working visit

The South African presidency reported on X on 19 November that Ramaphosa had been welcomed at Google by both James Manyika and Karan Bhatia, who leads Google’s global government affairs and public policy work. The post also mentioned a workshop on AI for digital trade and small businesses. [3]

Original English X post showing the welcome at Google and identifying the two hosts and the workshop.
South African presidency shows Ramaphosa arriving at Google

In his closing speech on 20 November, Ramaphosa referred to a contribution by venture capitalist Keet van Zyl during the meeting at Google. According to the president, Van Zyl had pointed out that time was running short to ensure no one was left behind. [6] Google lists Manyika as senior vice president for research, labs, technology and society. [7]

Mazhindu’s claim that there was no appointment is demonstrably false. The itinerary published on 12 November already listed Google for 19 November. The announced workshop and Ramaphosa’s account of what was discussed at Google show that the delegation was there to work. Chin’ono is right on this point. [3][4][6]

Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.

From the discussion

Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.

Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.

Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.

Loading comments…