News Made Clear · Loading…
News Made Clear · Loading…

US border arrests have fallen dramatically, but the White House’s claims about record-low crossings and millions of departures go further than the figures establish.
Review information is loading.
The White House said on 20 October that President Donald Trump had brought illegal border crossings to a historic low and that more than three million migrants had left the United States during his second term. Border Patrol’s provisional figures show a steep fall in arrests at the south-western border. They do not, however, establish how many migrants have departed, and the decline in border arrivals began before Trump returned to office. [1] [4] [8]
Border Patrol recorded 98,708 arrests between official crossing points on the south-western border in the financial year ending 30 September 2026, according to figures reported by KVIA. Border authorities compared that with more than 1.8 million arrests a year under Joe Biden — a fall of roughly 95%. They separately reported 379,243 migrant encounters nationwide, a broader measure. Arrests are not a count of everyone who crosses the border, including those who evade detection. [4]
The administration describes the latest border figure as the lowest in US history. But a historical Border Patrol table records 96,641 south-western border encounters in 1968, and lower totals in earlier years. Recording practices and terminology have changed, so the comparison does not measure every crossing in either period; it does not support an unqualified record-low claim for recorded arrests. [1] [4] [5]
Nor can the whole decline be assigned to one presidency. The Congressional Budget Office says immigration in its ‘other foreign nationals’ category fell after a June 2024 order issued under Biden and declined further following later government actions. Researchers at the Deportation Data Project say most of the fall in border arrivals occurred in Biden’s final year. Equally, the CBO attributes much of its subsequent reduction in migration forecasts to actions taken by the Trump administration. Those findings point to changes under both presidents, not a precise division of their effects.
10 listed sources · explore evidence, limitations and provenance.
Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.
Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.
Ask your question with @newsmadeclear or @nmc. You may receive 5 starter credits once after checks on your confirmed email and browser. The offer is once per person; extra accounts do not entitle you to another bonus. There is no monthly refill. Previous balances remain. A question costs 1 credit, including additional research you permit. A source you provide that demonstrably improves the article earns 5 credits. If your question helps Astra find the missing source and improve the article, you receive 1 credit back.
Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.
Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.
Loading comments…
Interested in advertising with News Made Clear? Explore our pilot.
The White House also says the population living in the US without legal immigration status has fallen by at least 2.3 million, while more than three million migrants have left and nearly 1.2 million people have been deported or removed. It does not set out calculations or definitions that show how those three figures relate. [1]
The 2.3 million figure matches a preliminary estimate by the Center for Immigration Studies, which put the population without legal status at 15.8 million in January 2025 and 13.5 million in July 2026. Its co-author Steven Camarota says this is a *net change* in the estimated population: arrivals, departures, deaths and people gaining legal status all affect it. It is not a tally of departures. [2] [3]
That estimate draws on a monthly household survey. The Census Bureau warns that changes in the survey’s relatively small foreign-born sample can reflect sampling variation and advises against using changes in the estimated population to calculate migration flows. The Center for Immigration Studies says it found no clear evidence that reduced survey participation explains the fall. [2] [6]
The White House’s further claim that US net migration turned negative in 2025 is contested. Brookings researchers estimate a net loss of 10,000 to 295,000 people in the calendar year; the CBO estimates a net gain of about 410,000. The Census Bureau’s estimate of a 1.3 million net gain covers a different period, from July 2024 to June 2025. [1] [7] [8] [9]
Enforcement inside the US has intensified: the Deportation Data Project found that deportations following ICE arrests in January 2026 ran at five times their average monthly rate in the second half of 2024. But its researchers say ICE and border-agency removal records probably overlap and cannot be combined into a reliable total without knowing by how much. Their findings show a substantial rise in interior enforcement, but do not establish the White House’s cumulative removal figure.