
Alaska vote data cannot confirm Trump’s claim about Dan Sullivan’s namesake
A BBC analysis found that more ballots for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr ranked Mary Peltola second than Senator Dan S. Sullivan. The rankings do not show whether voters confused the two men.
Review information is loading.
Donald Trump has claimed that everyone who voted for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr in Alaska’s Senate race meant to support the sitting Republican senator, Dan S. Sullivan. But voting data shows that more of the namesake’s ballots ranked Democrat Mary Peltola second than ranked the senator second, according to BBC Verify.
In its analysis of ballots that put Daniel J. Sullivan Jr first, 29% listed Peltola as their second choice and 15% listed Senator Sullivan. Another 17% chose Republican Gerald Heikes, 1% a write-in candidate, and 38% had no valid second choice. The BBC said its analysis covered the count at approximately 97%; it did not give the exact number of ballots analysed.
Those rankings do not reveal what individual voters were thinking. Some may have confused the candidates, including among the ballots with no valid second choice, but the figures do not establish how many did so.
Trump made his claim at a White House press conference on 9 November. The following day, he called for votes cast for the namesake and another candidate to be given to the senator, according to an archive of his Truth Social post.
The BBC’s later snapshot of first-choice votes, published on 17 November, put Peltola on 140,637 and Senator Sullivan on 129,424, with an estimated 97.4% counted. Daniel J. Sullivan Jr had 4,652 votes and Heikes had 6,002. Adding all of both candidates’ first-choice votes to the senator’s total would still have left him 559 behind Peltola at that point.
That calculation is a comparison of first choices, not a ranked-choice result. Under Alaska’s system, if no candidate wins more than half of first preferences, candidates are eliminated and their ballots can transfer to the next remaining choice. The count was not final, and the BBC reported that US media had not forecast a winner.
The two candidates were distinguished on the ballot: the senator was identified as the Republican incumbent, while his namesake appeared as Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. The New York Times reported a Democratic effort to recruit candidates who could draw support from the senator, including a search for people with his name. Peltola has denied knowing of a scheme, and Sullivan Jr has denied links with her campaign.
Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.
About this discussion and AI questions
Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.
Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.
Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.
Loading comments…