Trump backs Netanyahu with Iran claims that go beyond the evidence

There is strong evidence of damage to Iran’s export trade. Reuters reported on 16 October that Kpler recorded zero Iranian crude-oil exports in September — the first month without a shipment since the analytics company began tracking the producer in 2013. That is a major loss of trade, but it does not measure all Iran’s financial resources. [8]

The report also identified some liquefied petroleum gas and jet-fuel shipments since July, describing them as a fraction of Iran’s former energy exports. The US Treasury questioned tracking evidence suggesting vessels had evaded the blockade, saying ships could falsify their locations or identities. Those reported exceptions do not erase the scale of the export losses. [8]

Trump’s assertion that Iran would have fulfilled its threats is a separate question. He called their execution “only a question of time”. RFE/RL reported on 8 February 2019 that Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said the “Death to America” slogan targeted Trump and other US leaders, not the American public. That explanation still contained hostile rhetoric; neither it nor the slogan establishes an inevitable future act of destruction. [1] [6]

Pressure before the vote

The endorsement gives no attack date. In a separate post on 8 October, Trump had said the US would not attack Iran before the American midterm elections on 3 November. His new message does not explicitly withdraw that pledge. [5] [1]

Axios reported on 13 October, citing unnamed US and Israeli officials and another source, that Trump and Netanyahu had discussed renewed strikes before the elections. A White House official denied that the leaders had discussed resuming the war. [10]

Trump had withheld explicit electoral support for months amid disagreements with Netanyahu over Iran and Gaza, according to the Associated Press. He told Axios on 18 October that the timing was deliberate: “I was always going to do that. I just didn’t want to do it too soon.” [9] [11]

Likud attached a 35-second video of the two leaders to Netanyahu’s message of thanks. Netanyahu’s main rival, Gadi Eisenkot, said the election was a domestic matter for Israeli citizens to decide, Axios reported. [9] [11]

Asked by Axios whether he could work with another Israeli leader, Trump replied: “Maybe I will, maybe I won’t. Who wants to take the chance?” [11]

That is a warning about Trump’s willingness to work with a successor, not evidence that a successor could not be a US partner. Iran’s severe losses do not establish Netanyahu as the only possible choice.