All news articles

Israel policy divides Schumer and Van Hollen as Senate leadership vote approaches

The candidates differ over arms sales to Israel, but senators are also weighing wider questions about the party’s direction ahead of a secret ballot.

Chuck Schumer (second from left) with fellow lawmakers outside the US Capitol in an archival photograph
Chuck Schumer (second from left) with fellow lawmakers outside the US Capitol in an archival photograph · · George Miller · CC BY 2.0 · Archive photograph, for illustration
Loading statistics…

Senator Chris Van Hollen’s challenge to Chuck Schumer has brought their differences over US policy towards Israel into the contest to lead the incoming Democratic Senate majority. But with most eligible voters yet to declare a choice publicly, it remains unclear whether that issue will determine the result.

The leadership vote is scheduled for 1 December and will be held by secret ballot. Schumer says he has the votes to stay on; Van Hollen has called himself the underdog.

As of 18 November, The Washington Post counted 16 of the 55 eligible voters, including Schumer himself, publicly supporting him and five, including Van Hollen, backing the challenger. Four others opposed Schumer without endorsing Van Hollen, while 30 were uncommitted. If all 55 vote, a candidate needs 28 votes to win.

Van Hollen has said his bid is “much bigger than” Israel policy, presenting his challenge as a response to economic inequality and political corruption. Schumer’s supporters have pointed to his role in the Democrats’ midterm gains.

The Israel issue matters to some senators. Pennsylvania’s John Fetterman, a Schumer supporter, has described Van Hollen as hostile to Israel. Hawaii senator Mazie Hirono, who also backs Schumer, said she respected Van Hollen’s leadership on Israel but pointed to her long working relationship with Schumer.

Different votes, some common ground

In April, Van Hollen voted to bring a resolution objecting to a proposed US arms sale to Israel out of committee; Schumer voted against doing so. The motion failed. CNN reports that Van Hollen has supported resolutions to block weapons sales to Israel over the past two years, while Schumer has opposed them.

The two men also have common ground. In September, both voted to advance a resolution requesting information on Israel’s human rights practices. That procedural motion failed by 47 votes to 51.

Van Hollen has also criticised Schumer for siding with the pro-Israel lobbying group AIPAC in some Democratic primaries and called for the party’s Senate campaign committee to reject money from the group and its allies.

In Michigan’s Democratic Senate primary, Schumer backed Haley Stevens while Van Hollen endorsed Abdul El-Sayed, CNN reported. Schumer subsequently backed El-Sayed.

AIPAC’s super PAC, the United Democracy Project, spent about $30.6 million independently in the primary, according to VoteLog’s analysis of Federal Election Commission filings. Of that, $10.5 million supported Stevens and $20.1 million opposed El-Sayed. Those expenditures concerned the primary, not the leadership ballot.

In Maryland, the same super PAC spent $5.7 million supporting Adrian Boafo in a House primary, according to a separate compilation by Paid for Politics. Van Hollen criticised AIPAC’s involvement in that race, although his own leadership political committee later gave Boafo $3,000 for the general election. His spokesperson told CNN that he was focused on the broader goal of getting money out of politics.

Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.

From the discussion

Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.

Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.

Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.

Loading comments…