All news articles

Poppy Jay says two days trying tradwife lifestyle left her exhausted

Poppy Jay says trying the household routine of a Yorkshire tradwife for a BBC documentary left her exhausted. Her account highlights both the demands of the work and the dispute over traditional gender roles.

AI-generated editorial illustration based on the published article topic; not a documentary photograph.
Loading statistics…

Broadcaster Poppy Jay says two days taking on the household duties of a British tradwife left her exhausted, as she tried the lifestyle for a BBC documentary about women who embrace traditional gender roles at home.

For the programme *Young, British and Tradwife*, Jay spent three days with Molly and Aaron Edwards, an evangelical Christian couple in Yorkshire with seven children. On two days, she helped Molly cook, teach the children at home, tend the garden and look after chickens.

“I was exhausted,” Jay told the BBC. She said she was struck by the relentless pace of Molly’s work, which included cooking, cleaning and laundry, and said Molly had barely a moment to herself.

The tradwife movement centres on women taking responsibility for domestic work and child-rearing while their husbands act as breadwinners. Its supporters describe it as a return to traditional family values; critics say it reinforces gender inequality and limits women’s autonomy.

Molly Edwards, who has followed the lifestyle for more than 15 years, says it is rooted in her Christian faith and belief that women should serve their families under their husbands’ leadership. Aaron Edwards said in the documentary that submission matters when his wife disagrees with him, and described overruling her on decisions about how to organise the day.

Jay, who said she grew up in a conservative Muslim family and entered an arranged marriage at 19, said some of the household work felt familiar. But she disagreed with the idea that men should be in charge of everything. She said she came away respecting Molly and understanding some of the appeal, while finding submission the hardest part to accept.

The BBC report also describes how social media can turn the lifestyle into a source of income. Megan Landreth-Smith, a mother of three in West Sussex, said brand deals provide extra income. Yorkshire-based life coach Laura Zachary promotes an online course on “Biblical Wifery”; she said disagreement in comments can attract more people and increase earnings.

A King’s College London report cited by the BBC found that 79% of women surveyed were drawn to the calm, relaxed lifestyle portrayed in tradwife content. Its co-author, Professor Heejung Chung, warned that such imagery can draw some people towards far-right or nationalist ideas that seek to restrict women’s autonomy. The report also found that most young women and men surveyed held largely progressive views on gender roles, and that people who liked the content were attracted to its lifestyle imagery rather than traditional divisions of labour or power.

Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.

From the discussion

Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.

Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.

Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.

Loading comments…