All news articles

AI ANALYSIS & OPINION

Trump’s claim he saved US from destruction by ‘open borders’ lacks evidence

Border encounters fell sharply after Donald Trump returned to office, but they were already declining under Joe Biden. The figures do not show that the US was close to destruction or that Trump prevented it.

AI-generated editorial illustration based on the published article topic; not a documentary photograph.
Loading statistics…

In a Truth Social post on 22 November, Trump wrote: “OPEN BORDERS DESTROY NATIONS! The USA was very close to being one of them until I came along!” He did not specify a time period or define what he meant by a nation being destroyed. At a news conference two days earlier, he had compared his border record with Biden’s.

Border Patrol encounters between official crossings on the US-Mexico border fell from 249,740 in December 2023, a peak, to 47,320 in December 2024, when Biden was still president. They fell further to 8,349 in February 2025, Trump’s first full month back in office, according to Customs and Border Protection figures compiled by the Pew Research Center. For October 2026, the White House cited a Fox News report based on Homeland Security and border agency figures putting Border Patrol apprehensions at 8,288 on the south-west border.

Encounters are enforcement events, not a count of individual migrants or of people who stayed in the country: someone can be recorded more than once.

The earlier pressure was substantial. Federal officers recorded 2.1 million encounters at and between crossings on the south-west border in fiscal 2024, including 1.5 million Border Patrol apprehensions between crossings, according to the Congressional Research Service. The service also reported that immigration courts had a backlog of 3.5 million cases in the third quarter of that fiscal year, with border cases contributing to it.

Biden restricted entry for certain migrants and tightened asylum rules in June 2024. Mexico also increased migration enforcement earlier that year, according to the Migration Policy Institute. On 20 January 2025, Trump issued a proclamation Independently verifiedDCPD202500113 and restricting access to asylum for migrants it described as involved in an ‘invasion’ at the southern border. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has identified increased enforcement as one factor behind the decline in people crossing without encountering a border officer. The data do not isolate the contribution of each measure.

The CBO estimated that the immigration surge beginning in 2021 imposed a direct net cost of $9.2 billion on state and local governments in 2023, or 0.3% of their spending after federal grants were excluded. That accounts for both the cost of services and additional tax revenues. The highly uncertain estimate includes people who had permission to enter or stay as well as those without it; local effects could differ substantially.

At the 20 November news conference, Trump made a separate claim: ‘For the last 18 months, not one person has come into our country illegally.’ That is false. Using Homeland Security data, the CBO estimated a rate of about 1,300 people a month entering the US without encountering a border official in June 2025. That month falls within the period Trump described.

The White House has separately claimed 18 months of zero releases at the border. A release after an encounter is different from an entry without one.

After the midterm elections, Trump told CBS News that his immigration policy had ‘both helped and hurt’ him politically. He added that his deportation policy ‘might be too tough’, pointing to the removal of people who had jobs in the US.

On Independently verifiedwww.supremecourt.gov, the US Supreme Court agreed to hear a challenge to the legality of Trump’s border proclamation. The fall in encounters is substantial, but it does not establish that national destruction was imminent or that Trump prevented it.

Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.

From the discussion

Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.

Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.

Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.

Loading comments…