
Supreme Court declines Maryland gun-law challenge as Thomas questions broad restrictions
The Supreme Court declined to review Maryland’s gun-carry restrictions. Justice Clarence Thomas said many broad limits on carrying firearms in designated public places raise serious constitutional doubts, but the court did not rule on their legality.
Review information is loading.
The US Supreme Court has declined to hear a challenge to Maryland’s restrictions on carrying guns in designated public places, while Justice Clarence Thomas said he had “serious doubts” about many such laws and urged the court to consider them in a narrower case.
The court’s 16 November order leaves the constitutional question unresolved. Thomas agreed with the decision not to take the case, Novotny v. Moore, saying the challenge covered laws tied to distinct historical traditions and would make review difficult. He said the court should examine particular restrictions in an appropriate future case.
Maryland bars firearms in places including public demonstrations, mass transit, healthcare facilities, venues serving alcohol for on-site consumption, and state parks and forests. The state’s restrictions were upheld by the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, which found that each prohibited location qualified as a “sensitive place”.
Thomas argued that the historical record supports only a limited category of sensitive places, citing legislative assemblies, polling places and courthouses as examples. He said some modern restrictions reach locations with little resemblance to those places, and listed provisions in New Jersey, New York and California as examples. His statement expressed his view; the Supreme Court did not rule on the merits of Maryland’s laws or those other restrictions.
The court has previously said that historical analogies can help determine whether modern restrictions are permissible, while warning against expanding the category so broadly that it would undermine the general right to carry firearms in public. The Maryland case’s rejection does not decide where that boundary lies.
Sign in to give this article a thumbs up or down.
About this discussion and AI questions
Private test discussion. Comments are readers’ views and are not yet automatically fact-checked. Editing is available for 60 seconds after posting.
Sign in with a confirmed reader account and choose a username to read comments and participate.
Sorting applies to top-level comments; replies remain oldest first. New comments and likes can change the order. Refresh for the current ranking.
Loading comments…